On the cloud journey: How to avoid the 5 stages of storage grief

by HPStorage-Guest on 02-24-2012 03:56 PM - last edited 3 weeks ago

Brad.jpg By Brad Parks, Converged Infrastructure strategist, HP Storage   @HPBradParks

(Editor's note: You can read this post in German, Spanish, Italian, Portuguese, and French)

 

A step-by-step approach to moving from static to dynamic utility storage to support virtualization and cloud computing

 

They say that cloud is a journey. For most, it’s one fraught with challenges, obstacles, and, yes, grief, particularly when it comes to storage.

 

Having spent nine years managing a service provider data center, I can attest to the emotional attachment we have with infrastructure.  The job often forces us to spend more time with machines than our family. 

 

1284005724Jv64Il.jpgWith that in mind, I thought it could be fun to examine the parallelisms in the death of an old IT model as we move to cloud… Taking some liberties with the Kübler-Ross model for the five stages of grief, let’s find our happy place.

 

1.  Denial: “My current storage is fine.”

It’s time to face reality - the era of the storage silo is over.  Most of today’s storage was architected around the same time as the first web browser… dual-controller monolithic systems supporting predictable, physical workloads.

 

While these systems have been upgraded over the years, foundational gaps are revealing themselves.  Look at today’s data center – virtualization, cloud and an explosion of big data content – all unpredictable workloads that require a different approach.

 

2.     Anger: “I was told this system would be great for cloud.”

The goal of cloud is to enable the transparent delivery of IT “as-a-service.” Service delivery starts with a massively shared physical infrastructure.  Just ask public cloud service providers like Savvis that use common elements to host infrastructure, platform and software services. 

 

I’d like to dig into three critical design elements based on HP’s experience as the storage platform for four of five leading service providers in the Gartner Magic Quadrant Leaders Quadrant:

 

  • Dynamic multi-tenancy to deal with diverse unpredictable workloads
  • Efficient use of resources to align cost with revenue or chargeback
  • Management automation to speed service delivery

 

3.     Bargaining: “My system does all that.”

On the off chance your fragile emotional state has you bargaining the future ROI of your cloud initiative lets dig into how HP 3PAR Utility Storage uniquely addresses these areas.

 

Dynamic multi-tenancy:  With cloud you have many applications fighting for the same resources.  3PAR eliminates the need to fight.  Massive parallelism is achieved with a mesh-active design where all applications securely access the power of the whole cluster.  Additionally, the system separates the processing of control functions and actual data IO. Translation: the video streaming program doesn’t choke your mission-critical OLTP database.  And it does it transparently… without any manual tuning.  This optimization has allowed many service providers to double the virtual machine density on their servers and contributed to the 450,000+ SPC-1 IOPS delivered by a SINGLE 3PAR system.

 

Efficient use of resources: Cost is a major driver to public cloud providers.  For private cloud to compete, you must get the most from every dollar and disk.  HP 3PAR accomplishes this with a 4th-gen zero-detect ASIC.  In lay terms, the system sucks the fat from provisioned volumes and constantly hunts down empty 16k segments.  (Watch @HPStorageGuy Calvin Zito hunt down some fat in this zero-detect lab.)

 

But it’s not enough just to run thin; you must do it without sacrificing performance.  Unlike other “bolt-on” thin storage implementations, with 3PAR you can run performance sensitive applications in a thin state without impacting SLAs.  Ask your current array provider if they can do that… not all thin is equal.  The proof is in the HP Get Thin 50% capacity savings guarantee.

 

Management automation: Much like the human respiratory system, 3PAR performs many core tasks on its own as they are needed – autonomically.  An example is 3PAR Adaptive Optimization that moves blocks between SSD and HDD to balance cost and performance.  It extends to provisioning… as IT folks we don’t always get things right the first time so it’s important to not only provision but also re-provision easily.  With 3PAR it takes 2 mouse clicks and causes zero application disruption.  (Want to see Calvin provisioning a volume?)

 

Management is also important in the context of the cloud stack.  An example is the fully automated provisioning that we can do through service portals with HP’s storage provisioning manager as part of HP CloudSystem.  This level of integration is only possible when you have server, storage, and networking engineering under the same roof.  It allows an administrator to define QoS standards so that all cloud services, including storage volumes can be provisioned without any admin bottleneck.

 

4.     Depression: “What do I do now?”

Obviously you are at an IT vendor web site so I wouldn’t leave you hanging… HP can help.  We can eliminate the boundaries between storage and the rest of IT and accelerate the path to cloud.

 

Enterprises evolve at different speeds.  If you are just now amplifying your virtualization effort or scoping a hybrid cloud project any gains you make in storage agility and efficiency will serve you well.  HP and our channel partners offer a range of service engagement options to help you blueprint your path to cloud nirvana and architect a transition plan to get you there.  Examples are the HP Cloud Assessment and Discovery Workshops.

I’ve embedded quite a few links into this post but here are a few more you may want to check out:

 

>> Buy 50% less storage capacity… Guaranteed!

>> Thin Conversion and Storage Federation with HP 3PAR(Video)

>> Converged storage for the new era of computing

>> HP positioned as a leader in the Magic Quadrant for Midrange and High-End Modular Disk Arrays by Gartner

>> Flip through the full set of 3PAR related posts

 

5. Acceptance: “I’m ready to get started.”

Great!  Thanks for taking the time to read this whole post.  What trials and tribulations have you found on the pathway to cloud? Any best practices or tips to share with the rest of the class? 

 

For those in the United States, we are going to be hitting the road soon with a travelling HP event focused on the path to cloud. Check to see if we are coming to your town with the HP Pathways to Cloud Road Show 2012 and sign up now.

 

I’d love to meet you at the event, hear from you on this blog or chat with you on Twitter – @HPBradParks.

We encourage you to share your comments on this post. Comments are moderated and will be reviewed and posted as promptly as possible during regular business hours.

To ensure your comment is published, please follow our community guidelines.

Comments
by nate on 02-26-2012 09:24 PM

Funny to think that HP, as a company went through pretty much those same steps with having the EVA and the XP and Lefthand as storage platforms before buying 3PAR.

 

I remember a big vmware conference up in Seattle (moved to Cali last July), they had one really big conference a year where a bunch of vendors came out and put on presentations and stuff.  This was the year before HP bought 3PAR if I recall right. I went into a conference on HP storage, I was curious what the strategy was for HP storage and VMware. The guy on the stage was from Lefthand and all he talked about was Lefthand/P4000 for the 45 minute or so time period. I don't recall any mention of any other HP storage products. At the end of the presentation (much like at the end of a Dell presentation on Equallogic at another event at another point in time) I felt glad I was a 3PAR user. I wanted to say things to the guy but ended up not. Unlike my Equallogic event experience I don't recall specifically what the P4000 platform was lacking that I liked in 3PAR at the time this was a while ago.

 

I did try out the P4000 VSA recently and found the UI to be overly complicated,  took me a couple of hours to get storage exported to a host, mainly because I didn't understand how the networking was supposed to work and there was routing issues between the VSA and the host. Also I had to specify the ISCSI address of the client I was connecting (I didn't see a way to browse connections and just add them like on 3PAR even with ISCSI).  The lack of 10GbE support in the VM the lack of jumbo frames, and apparently only 1 NIC supported were drawbacks I was not expecting from the VSA.

 

Someone I know up in Seattle calls Compellent the "poor man's 3PAR", companies that can't afford 3PAR often times go buy Compellent. I thought about that, and thought it was funny Dell was the same way, they couldn't afford to buy 3PAR so they went and bought Compellent!

 

I'm just waiting for the new stuff to come out of 3PAR, short of the V-class platform there really hasn't been anything new from 3PAR in a good two years now.

 

nate

(3par customer/user for past 5 years now)

by Anthony Buck(anon) on 03-01-2012 06:35 PM

With all the different places you can store email and other information.  Why haven't you got a printer that can just plug'n'play?  If your really are such a customer friendly company I know that it isn't imposable.  The idea of a one plug and power connection isn't new nor is it imposable..

by on 03-05-2012 04:05 PM

@Anthony - I plugged my LaserJet into my PC and it played, very well I might add and for many years.  In fact, it's still playing now.  Since we're not printer experts in HP Storage, I'd suggest reaching out to our colleagues in our printer organization if you have specific feedback. 

by Jenny(anon) on 03-07-2012 04:44 AM

Why is a block storage array positioned as cloud storage?  All the legacy vendors have this.  Cloud storage implies S3 API's, or possibliy tiering into those services.  It's hard to see why this isn't just another rehashed storage array with a slightly simpler GUI.  

by brad.parks on 03-08-2012 12:42 AM

@Jenny - Thanks for the comment... you hit on a good topic.  Storage for Cloud Computing vs. Cloud Storage.  We often have a similar conversation surrounding Storage for Virtual Servers vs. Storage Virtualization. 

 

While related they are absolutely not the same thing.  Cloud Storage as you point out implies access via cloud using object based interfaces like REST/SOAP.  The focus of this post however was Storage FOR Cloud Computing... the behind the scenes repository on the other side of that pipe.

 

Here is where I've got to disagree with you that all block storage is created equal.  The ability to deal with massive consolidation of mixed workloads without dropping performance, adding management complexity, or wasting any capacity is something that exposes the architectural choice points of various block arrays.  You mention 'rehashed storage arrays' and that's a good point...  we compare 3PAR (designed for these requirements from the ground up) to some of the arrays that have been in the market for over 20 years (rehashed and bolted-on features) and that is where we routinely are successful (as indicated in growth numbers in high-end storage bands).

 

The goal of this post was to point out what some of those architectural differences are and highlight (since we are on an HP blog) why we (and many of the leading cloud service providers) think that 3PAR implementation is most suited to be that back end store.

 

 

 

Post a Comment
Be sure to enter a unique name. You can't reuse a name that's already in use.
Be sure to enter a unique email address. You can't reuse an email address that's already in use.
Type the characters you see in the picture above.Type the words you hear.

Find HP in Social Media

Facebook Twitter YouTube SlideShare Flickr
About the Author
  • 25+ years experience around HP Storage. The go-to guy for news and views on all things storage..
  • This profile is for team blog articles posted. See the Byline of the article to see who specifically wrote the article.
Labels