Eye on Blades Blog: Trends in Infrastructure
Get HP BladeSystem news, upcoming event information, technology trends, and product information to stay up to date with what is happening in the world of blades.

SLC Flash and USB Keys for Integrated Hypervisors

The USB key that HP offers for integrated hypervisors inside ProLiant servers uses single-level cell (SLC) NAND flash, instead of the more common multi-level cell (MLC) technology.  Why SLC?  Because not all all USB keys are created equal. An SLC-based key will last about 10 times as long than a cheaper MLC-based USB stick you'd typically find in computer stores.

You don't need an especially reliable key if you're just using it to move software or install device drivers.   However, there are some good reasons why people install USB keys as a permanent boot device for integrated hypervisors like VMWare ESXi (Simon Seagrave describes the reasons on his Techhead site).  

SLC (Single Level Cell) and MLC (Multi-Level Cell) are two types of NAND flash memory usually used in USB keys, with MLC being much more common.  

SLC technology works by storing a single level of voltage (charge) in each memory cell.  That charge represents single bit of information. If the cell is charged, it represents a "1"; if the cell isn't charged, it represents a "0".  Each cell holds 1 bit of data.

MLC technology stores one of four different charge states in each cell. So each cell can either be uncharged, charged a little, charged a lot, or charged full.  Four different possible states ("00", "01", "10", and "11" in binary) means each cell stores 2 bits of information. 

So MLC has a cheaper cost per bit.  That makes it more popular with consumers, meaning more memory makers produce it...and supply-and-demand end up making MLC a lot cheaper than SLC.

However, the two technologies react differently to the biggest problem with NAND flash: wear-out.  NAND flash cells, whether SLC or MLC, can only survive a certain number of writes (changes to the charge state) before they degrade.  However, SLC can tolerate around 100,000 write cycles, while MLC can only endure 5,000 to 10,000 cycles.  So if you wrote to a single cell once every hour, an average cell in an MLC-based key would fail in about 1 year, while you'd get about 11 years of life out of an SLC-based key.

Now, a copy of ESXi actually doesn't do very many writes to its 'host' key. When ESXi  boots, it sets up a RAM disk in memory and mostly uses that, even for log files.  There are also usually two bootable images on each key, providing some redundancy; plus, if a key fails, it's relatively easy to restore the host to a new key.   All that being said, it's pretty rare in the data center to find a way to spend about $70 more to get a device with 10x the reliability.

Labels: ESXi| MLC| reliability| SLC| USB
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Do you mean 
Follow Us

About the Author(s)
  • More than 25 years in the IT industry developing and managing marketing programs. Focused in emerging technologies like Virtualization, cloud and big data.
  • I am a member of the Enterprise Group Global Marketing team blogging on topics of interest for HP Servers. Check out blog posts on all four Server blog sites-Reality Check, The Eye on Blades, Mission Critical Computing and Hyperscale Computing- for exciting news on the future of compute.
  • I work within EMEA HP Servers Central Team as a launch manager for new products and general communications manager for EMEA HP Server specific information. I also tweet @ServerSavvyElla
  • HP Servers, Converged Infrastructure, Converged Systems and ExpertOne
  • WW responsibility for development of ROI and TCO tools for the entire ISS portfolio. Technical expertise with a financial spin to help IT show the business value of their projects.
  • I am a member of the HP BladeSystem Portfolio Marketing team, so my posts will focus on all things blades and blade infrastructure. Enjoy!
  • Luke Oda is a member of the HP's BCS Marketing team. With a primary focus on marketing programs that support HP's BCS portfolio. His interests include all things mission-critical and the continuing innovation that HP demonstrates across the globe.
  • Global Marketing Manager with 15 years experience in the high-tech industry.
  • 20 years of marketing experience in semiconductors, networking and servers. Focused on HP BladeSystem networking supporting Virtual Connect, interconnects and network adapters.
  • Working with HP BladeSystem.
  • Greetings! I am on the HP Enterprise Group marketing team. Topics I am interested in include Converged Infrastructure, Converged Systems and Management, and HP BladeSystem.
The opinions expressed above are the personal opinions of the authors, not of HP. By using this site, you accept the Terms of Use and Rules of Participation.